top of page

"Recurring Courtroom Tactics: Unmasking the Industry-Wide Issue in Trucking Lawsuits"

The recurring legal battles within the trucking industry have become an alarming trend. Recently, another leading player has joined the list of defendants, facing serious accusations of safety failures, negligence, and violation of industry regulations. But far from being an isolated event, this lawsuit echoes familiar courtroom tactics and accusations seen in numerous similar cases across the industry. This case has underscored the urgent need for improved safety measures and more robust regulatory compliance.

Strong Takeaways from the Courtroom

  1. A Pattern of Training Deficiencies- The case highlights a common allegation in many industry lawsuits: the failure to adequately train drivers and employees. Industry-wide, there is a call for improved, regular, and intensive training programs that emphasize vehicle operation, emergency handling, adherence to HOS regulations, and the prohibition of handheld device use while driving.

  2. The Safety Protocol Conundrum- Inadequate safety programs are another familiar allegation in these lawsuits. To avoid such accusations, companies across the industry must invest in establishing robust safety protocols, including regular safety meetings, vehicle inspections, and driver evaluations, as well as strict enforcement of rules regarding handheld device use and HOS regulations.

  3. Supervision Failures- Lax supervision is a recurring theme in these cases. To mitigate this risk, companies must enforce an active supervision program. Measures like real-time tracking of trucks, regular check-ins with drivers, and the use of technology to monitor compliance with safety regulations could help reduce such claims in the courtroom.

  4. Hiring Practices Under Fire- Negligent hiring and retention practices form a regular part of the prosecution's arsenal in these lawsuits. To counter this, stringent hiring practices including background checks, drug testing, and driver history reviews are essential. Maintaining rigorous performance standards and enforcing a zero-tolerance policy towards violations can help ensure the recruitment and retention of only the most reliable drivers.

  5. Compliance with HOS Regulations- Repeated violations of HOS regulations, another common accusation, point to the industry's need for stricter enforcement of these rules. The implementation of digital logging devices can monitor drivers' hours and ensure compliance.

  6. Policy Enforcement on Handheld Device Use- Given the dangers of distracted driving, clear rules on using handheld devices while driving need to be strictly enforced. Training, monitoring, and implementing clear penalties for violations can mitigate the risks associated with this issue.

  7. Necessity of Regular Audits and Reviews- Finally, a recurring lesson from these lawsuits is the importance of regular audits of safety programs. Comprehensive audits can help identify potential weaknesses before they result in legal action.

These recurrent courtroom tactics reflect systemic problems in the trucking industry. But they also highlight potential solutions. By prioritizing comprehensive training, robust safety measures, active supervision, and strict compliance with regulations, companies can defend against these all-too-familiar accusations and, more importantly, protect their employees, the public, and themselves. These lawsuits, while alarming, present valuable opportunities for industry-wide learning and improvement.

36 views0 comments


bottom of page